Treatment Options for Dry Eye
The treatment we prescribe or recommend for you will be heavily influenced by the results of your specific dry eye assessment and targeted towards the form of dry eye disease you are diagnosed with.
It is important to understand that in many cases the treatment options for dry eye will enable you to manage but not necessarily cure the disease, so ongoing and repeated attention is frequently required. In some cases treatment may not result in significant improvement in symptoms, but is important to prevent progression of meibomian gland disease and of your dry eye condition worsening further.
Initial Non-Specific Treatment Options
For all dry eye sufferers there are a number of relatively simple and inexpensive strategies for the reduction and management of symptoms. These include:
Environmental modifications - minimising exposure to environmental hazards such as air-conditioning and heating; keeping interior environments well humidified; avoiding smoky environments; and wearing protective eyewear in challenging environments.
Occupational modifications - particularly relating to screen-based activities, by regularly blinking; by taking regular breaks from screen work; and by lowering screens below eye level.
Modification of medications - in conjunction with the appropriate health care practitioner (usually the GP) considering the ocular side-effects of systemic medications such as anti-histamines, anti-depressants, and HRT; and modifiying these where practicable.
Dietary and other nutritional supplementation - especially increasing dietary intake of omega-3 essential fatty acids found in fish such as salmon, trout, sardines, tuna and mackerel; this may be supplemented by products such as fish oil tablets.
Use of ocular lubricants - these include tear substitutes of varying viscosity, gels and ointments; often these are provided in non-preserved form.
Reduction or cessation of contact lens wear - contact lenses disrupt the tear film and will generally tend to exacerbate existing dry eye, so modification of the wearing schedule may be recommended.
Instituting basic eyelid therapy and hygiene - this includes the use of warm compresses, lid massage and lid scrubs where appropriate.
If anterior blepharitis is detected, this should generally be addressed prior to the commencement of other dry eye therapy. The mainstays of treatment for anterior blepharitis include:
Lid scrubs and lid hygiene measures - lid scrubs involve cleaning the lid margins with cotton buds moistened with products such as baby shampoo or with self-foaming pads or eyelid wipes. The purpose of lid scrubs is to remove all debris and matter from the lid margins, including any that might be blocking the meibomian glands.
Blephex™ - Blephex™ is a procedure performed in-office by the optometrist which provides a more thorough cleaning of the lids than lid scrubs by the use of a rotating brush. The fee for performing this procedure is $48 (in addition to the short consultation fee). Click here for more information about Blephex™.
Blephadex - Blephadex foam cleanser and eyelid wipes are for home use. The cleanser contains tea tree oil and is particularly effective against the Demodex mite that frequently contributes to the development of blepharitis and associated rosacea. Click here for more information about Blephadex.
Dry eye from aqueous insufficiency arises from reduced secretion of the lacrimal gland and causes tear hyperosmolarity, where the concentrations of tear salts and proteins become abnormally high. In turn this causes inflammation of the ocular surface, damage to the epithelial cells at the front of the eye, and an unstable tear film. Aqueous insufficiency is treated with some of the following :
Topical steroid drops - steroid drops such as Flarex and FML are frequently used in the first instance to reduce the inflammatory consequences of tear hyperosmolarity. Steroids are also helpful where there is co-existing meibomian gland disease because of their anti-inflammatory effect on the eyelids. They often bring rapid initial relief of symptoms but are not suitable for long-term use due to risks such as increased intra-ocular pressures, cataract, and reducing the eye's resistance to infection.
Restasis (cyclosporin A) - this drop protects and restores the functioning of the lacrimal gland, as well as reducing inflammation in the eye as steroids do, but is more difficult to obtain as it must be prepared by a compounding pharmacist.
Acetyl-cysteine - acetyl-cysteine can be used to dissolve the mucous that sometimes accumulates when tears have a low aqueous content. In eyedrop form, acetyl-cysteine must also be prepared by a compounding pharmacist.
Punctal plugs - when artificial tears and lubricants are insufficient to relieve the symptoms of aqueous deficient dry eye, punctal plugs are used to block the entry to the channels where the tears normally drain, allowing the tears to remain longer in contact with the eye. It is important to resolve all inflammation first before inserting these plugs. The fee for punctal plug insertion is $60 (in addition to the short consultation fee). Click here to view a short video on how punctal plugs work.
Meibomian Gland Dysfunction
As around 80% of cases of dry eye are evaporative due to mybomian gland dysfunction, this condition frequently requires treatment. Treatment strategies are aimed at either increasing the quantity of oils (meibum) produced by the glands or, more usually, unblocking glands and ensuring the free flow of oils from them. This typically requires the application of heat to "melt" and reduce the viscosity of old thickened oils remaining in the glands before mechanically expressing them. This may need to be repeated a number of times before satisfactory gland function is restored. Some of the treatments outlined above for aqueous insufficiency are also of use in treating evaporative dry eye..
Once the meibomian glands have been heated, there are a number of techniques and instruments that can be used to express the glands. Two examples are expression with forceps and expression with Mastrota Paddle. Although occasionally we employ forced expression of the glands like this to assess the quality of the meibum, generally we now use this relatively infrequently for treatment; even then, very gently rather than with significant force. Other methods for treating meibomian gland dysfunction include:
Restasis (cyclosporin A) - this drop protects and restores the functioning of the lacrimal gland, as well as reducing inflammation in the eye as steroids do, but is more difficult to obtain as it must be prepared by a compounding pharmacist. Being an antibiotic it also has anti-bacterial properties.
Topical azithromycin - like Restasis, azithromycin is an antibiotic that has been shown to have significant anti-inflammatory (as well as a less important anti-bacterial) effect on the eyelids. It must also be prepared by a compounding pharmacist.
In-office Blephasteam® & manual meibomian gland expression - Blephasteam® is a goggle-based eyelid warming device that provides moisture and heat in the form of steam, to be used prior to manual expression of the meibomian glands. These heating goggles are worn for about ten minutes prior to gland expression. As noted above, manual expression for treatment purposes tends to be employed infrequently and only at very gentle levels. Click here for more information on Blephasteam®
In-office LipiFlow® automated thermal pulsation treatment - Lipiflow® works on the same principles as Blephasteam® and manual meibomian gland expression, but more precisely controls the heat and pressure applied to the inner eyelids over a single treatment session that typically lasts around 15 minutes. Especially for more difficult and entrenched cases of meibomian gland dysfunction, LipiFlow® is often the treatment of choice due to its consistency and repeatability, and relatively gentle mode of action. Importantly, treatment by Lipiflow® is evidence based as its effectiveness has been verified by independent clinical research. Click here or here to read more about LipiFlow®, or click here to view video animations that explain meibomian gland disease and show how Lipiflow® works.
In-office IPL & manual meibomian gland expression - Intense Pulsed Light (IPL) was originally used by dermatologists for the treatment of rosacea. In the treatment of dry eye, IPL may be used to warm the meibomian glands prior to them sometimes being (gently) manually expressed, much in the way of Blephasteam®. IPL may also calm the small blood vessels that sometimes surround the meibomian glands. Typically IPL is conducted over three or four sessions. For more information about how IPL works, click here.
Reviews and Repeat Treatments
Whereas LipiFlow® typically involves only a single treatment followed by a review a few weeks later, both Blephasteam® and IPL followed by manual gland expression often require three or four treatment sessions on day 1, day 15, and day 45. Reviews are typically scheduled a few weeks after treatment has been completed, or at any time you feel a need to return.
Because your tear function will have been quantified objectively prior to treatment, improvements can be clearly demonstrated at subsequent reviews using the same tests that were conducted at your initial dry eye assessment.
Summary of Fees
Generally fees for the in-office procedures described above do not attract a Medicare rebate. If a consultation is also conducted in addition to the procedures, however, it may attract a rebate. A summary of the fees for each in-office procedure is as follows:
Tear osmolarity analysis $37.80
Blephex lid cleaning $48 *
Blephasteam and meibomian gland expression $48 *
Collagen punctal plugs $75 per plug
Permanent silicone punctal plugs $215 per plug
IPL and meibomian gland expression $720 for a course of 3 or 4 treatment sessions
LipiFlow automated thermal pulsation treatment $1,750 for a single session (this includes consumables, which cost around $500)
* Please note that for these visits a short consultation fee of $60.35 also applies, for which Medicare will provide a rebate of $28.45.
Click here for this information in pdf format.